Mad as Birds by M.C. Schmidt
Publisher: Black Rose Writing
Genre: Young Adult (14 – 18 y.o.), Sci-Fi/Fantasy, Mystery/Suspense/Thriller, Paranormal, Historical, Contemporary
Rating: 3 Stars
Reviewed by AstilbeMoving to an intentional community is supposed to be a fresh start for Milo. No Internet or television. Complete isolation from the outside world. He doesn’t love the idea of moving, but his brother has been in charge since their parents’ accident, and Milo knows better than to question him. Besides, it’s not like there’s anything to stay for, not after the recent incident that got him expelled from school and made him a social pariah.
Milo is intrigued when he learns their new home was once a retreat for famous artists. He’s a talented painter himself. So, when a spectral woman begins to show up whenever he’s at his easel, he initially takes her for a muse. Seduced by the quality of the work they’re making, he doesn’t notice the control she’s gaining over him. By the time he learns her true intentions, it might be too late for him to overpower her—but if he can’t find a way soon, she’s going to force him to slaughter every resident of the community.
The past can never be forgotten.
Milo was a wonderfully nuanced character. The incident that got him expelled from school was a serious one, and I was intrigued by the fact that so many different versions of that story were floating around. Other readers should decide for themselves which version of it they believe as they’re reading, of course, but I enjoyed the contradictions between them as I tried to figure out if the protagonist’s recollection of it was the full truth or maybe something else entirely.
It would have been helpful to have deeper plot development. I noticed a few plot holes related to how the residents of the intentional community ended up living in an old, abandoned mansion that I wished had been explained in greater detail as that aspect was quickly brushed over. There were so many excellent reasons why the average person would not want to live in such an isolated and run-down place where using a cellphone or laptop was forbidden that this reader needed some stronger counterarguments for why this was the best option for all of them. This is something I’m saying as someone who was otherwise excited to check this tale out and really wanted to give it a higher rating.
With that being said, I did enjoy the plot twists involving the paranormal elements of the storyline. They aren’t that commonly used in this genre these days from what I’ve observed, so I was curious to find out how they would play out in this universe as the same patterns played out over and over again as the characters attempted to break the cycle. This is the sort of theme I love reading about in this genre, and it makes me curious to check out more stories from the author in the future.
Mad as Birds was a wild ride.




































