The Charterhouse Remains by Rhys Dylan (writing as Dylan Young)
Publisher: Wrynmwood Press
Genre: Contemporary, Mystery/Suspense/Thriller
Rating: 4 stars
Reviewed by Fern

On the hottest day of the year, 11-year-old Blair Smeaton vanishes near a riverbank, leaving police baffled and desperate. Detective Anna Gwynne, still haunted by her recent trauma, uncovers a sinister connection to an unsolved case. A chilling dark web photo reveals Blair trapped in the same room where a previous victim was once held captive ten years earlier. A captive whose remains, found near Charterhouse in the Mendip Hills, form the basis of the cold case she’s investigating.

The killer isn’t hiding; he’s taunting.

With Blair’s life hanging by a thread, Anna turns to a dangerous contact who can navigate the murky waters of the internet. But will trusting him save Blair—or cost Anna everything?

DI Anna Gwynne is almost recovered from the brutal ending of her previous case, but despite that she’s eager to return to work and a sense of normalcy. Her team continues to review and investigate cold cases, and it’s the unsolved child kidnapping that draws Anna fully back to work. When a recent photo on the dark web links their cold case with a very recent similar child kidnapping Anna and her team are once again drawn into a deadly game they still don’t fully understand.

This is the second book in the Black Squid trilogy and I found it every bit as gripping and well written as the first book. This kidnapping case and the particulars surrounding it can definitely be read as a stand alone book I feel – but the overall arc of this trilogy and some of the bigger picture items might have more emotional impact on the reader if they go back and read the trilogy in order. I absolutely enjoyed both these book a lot but as a police procedural and mystery this can be thoroughly enjoyed alone too.

I admit that I really enjoy Anna’s character. She’s different in many ways to Dylan’s other characters – especially those in his main series (DI Evan Warlow – another exceptional series to pick up) in that she uses her intuition rather a lot more than most police detective series that I’ve read.

I completely understand this won’t be every readers cup of tea – using instinct and even their dreams to help lead them down their investigative paths and to be fair Anna is a very long way from fully relying on these tools. There is ample amounts of following evidence, forensics, interviews and all the regular processes. I just really enjoy – and find refreshing and interesting – the fact Anna is a lot more open to listening to her subconscious making connections and even being open minded to rather more unusual voices of opinion. I feel this really sets this book and trilogy apart from the rest and for me, personally, I thoroughly enjoy it and would love a whole lot more of it.

Readers looking for a slightly different police procedural, full of well layered plot, different and interesting characters plus a bit more leaning into the thriller aspect and not just the regular mystery/suspense style of plot – this trilogy should absolutely be up your alley. These themes are a little darker than the usual fare – a little gritter and for those who like a bit more bite to their mystery and not the more cosy style.

A thoroughly gripping mystery and I’m very eager to read the final installment in this trilogy. Recommended.

Druid’s Moor by Rhys Dylan
Publisher: Wyrmwood Press
Genre: Contemporary, Mystery/Suspense/Thriller
Rating: 4 stars
Reviewed by Fern

On the moor, not all the beasts walk on four legs.

On a windswept moor, a child emerges from the mist with a story no one wants to believe. The farmer who finds her assumes she’s simply lost. But when she utters a chilling phrase—“We went to see the old ones”—he realises something is terribly wrong.

As Detective Evan Warlow battles his own demons, he and the team are pulled into a case of ritualistic secrets, long-buried crimes, and the whispers of something darker lurking in the mist.

In the empty heart of Wales, legends are harmless. It’s the people you need to fear.

It’s Christmas-time and the shortest day of the year. A farmer out in his field in the bitterly cold early morning hours finds a young girl, wandering alone, in shock and clearly hypothermic. The Rural crimes team contact DI Warlow, uneasy with the simple, pat answers being given to them. As the team investigate further what they begin to uncover might ruin the festive season for them all and have longer-lasting repercussions.

I have been a solid fan of this Welsh based series for quite a while now. While I do admit this book in particular has a number of hooks and links to a longer running plot arc over the previous few books, I still feel it’s such a deeply emotional and well plotted book that it’s well worth the effort to give it a go. The characters in this story are really beginning to come into their own – the team working brilliantly together but each of them strong and able to deliver independently. And while there are a few different moving parts to the various sub-plots, I feel the author really should be commended on how well and intricately this was all woven together. It’s an exceptional read.

I was also thrilled at a strong secondary plot involving DI Anna Gwynne. I have read the first of that trilogy – having accidently stumbled across it just a month or so ago – and while there are no real spoilers Anna’s interactions with the Warlow team has absolutely bumped up the other two books in her trilogy up my to read list order.

Readers who enjoy a slightly grittier police procedural mystery should absolutely find this an enjoyable book. It’s quite a way into the series, but I do think it can be easily picked up by itself. Some of the longer-running plots might feel more emotional and give a deeper satisfaction having read some of the more recent previous books, but I definitely think readers can dive right in here and still find a solidly plotted, well written mystery with varied and interesting characters.

A great read. Recommended.